
Avatar:
Fire and Ash is
the first film in the Avatar series not to be nominated for Best Picture, and
it’s probably not too difficult to ascertain why. It’s mostly the same story
arc as the previous films, just with a new villain. Well, a new additional
villain. A lot of the same themes get covered: there’s another environmental
crisis, and there’s the same struggle between the native people and the
colonizers. There’s a big confrontation between the native people and the
colonizers, of course, and the visual effects are the primary focus throughout.
The twist, if there is one, is that this time there’s a group of Na’vi, the
Mangkwan, who are participating in the destruction of their own world and
attacking other Na’vi because The Mangkwan have rejected the worshiping of
Eywa. They also start partnering with Stephen Lang’s Quaritch, the villain from
the two previous movies, and he and the other colonizers introduce guns to this
tribe of Navi, and it’s not going to end well for anyone. Anyone who’s ever
seen a Western film knows where this is headed. The film spends a lot of time
focusing on the young human with white skin, Spider (Jack Champion), who left
his awful father (Quaritch) in the previous film to join the Na’vi. Neytiri (Zoe
Saldana) is reluctant to accept him and welcome him into their home because of
his skin color, so it’s possible that the filmmakers are trying to make a point
about racism in a movie mostly populated by tall blue people. It’s not
particularly clear what that point might be, though, since everyone seems to
have enemies who have the same skin color and enemies who have a different skin
color. Kiri (voiced by Sigourney Weaver) saves Spider after his oxygen mask fails
by connecting him to the earth and undergoing the ritual that revives him and
allows him to breathe the air of Pandora. This change leads the colonizers to capture
Spider to see if they can reverse engineer his DNA so that they too could
benefit from the secret to living without a mask. As you might expect from a
James Cameron directed film, the visuals are stunning. This is the third film
in the franchise to win for Best Achievement in Visual Effects, and they go
hand-in-hand with the cinematography. I’m still not a fan of wearing those
stupid 3D glasses over my regular prescription glasses, but eventually I adjust
and just feel like I’m immersed in the world of Pandora again. I’m just not
certain what message or messages we are meant to take from this film. Is this a
movie cautioning the viewers about ruthless leaders? Is it an attempt to be
subversive by suggesting that we combat their ideas even if they align
themselves with people who might seemingly be on our side become of our common
traits? The filmmakers, sadly, are not fully effective in making any of these
points. I’m also troubled by the depiction of the Mangkwan in the film; they
appear very similar to native tribes from, say, the Amazon or other parts of
South America or Central America. It’s not a flattering depiction either. By
the way, here’s another piece of Oscar trivia for you. Avatar: Fire and
Ash is the first film directed by Cameron in 31 years not to be
nominated for Best Picture. If the series continues, as he says it will,
perhaps he should comfort himself with all the money he makes rather than
expecting more Oscar glory.
Oscar
Win: Best
Achievement in Visual Effects
Other
Oscar Nomination:
Best Achievement in Costume Design